Paper Pieces Reviews

Paper Pieces has an overall rating of 3.6 based on 15 reviews. Customer feedback on Paper Pieces is mixed.

3.6/5.0

15 reviews

5 Stars

7

4 Stars

5

3 Stars

3

2 Stars

3

1 Star

2

All Paper Pieces Reviews (15)
TORO
May 20, 2026
"I was kind of disappointed with..."
I was kind of disappointed with my order from Paper Pieces. Some of the pieces I received were not the sizes I had ordered, and one item just wasn’t in the package at all. The packaging was fine, nothing bad there, but when you need certain shapes for a project, the right ones getting sent really matters. Customer service did reply to me, so that was okay, but everything got slowed down because of it. Overall, not the best experience for me.
roger.Dunham
May 16, 2026
"Easy ordering, just a little slow"
Ordering from paperpieces.com was simple. I was able to find the size I needed without digging around too much, and checkout went smoothly... which I always appreciate with craft sites.

The confirmation email showed up quickly, and when my order arrived, everything was correct. The packaging was decent too, nothing was bent or messed up.

I’m only taking off one star because the shipping felt a bit slow, but it wasn’t awful or anything. I’d still order from them again when I need more pieces...
james.Violette
May 13, 2026
"The paper pieces were accurate overall..."
The paper pieces were accurate overall. They fit together well enough and I didn’t run into any major issues.
willie_Trautman92
May 12, 2026
"Decent, but not quite worth the wait"
My order showed up in good condition and the pieces were usable, so in that sense it met my basic expectations. I just expected a little more for the price. Shipping took longer than I thought it would, and for what I paid, I was hoping the overall experience would feel a bit more impressive. It was okay, just nothing I’d be excited to reorder right away.
RickyEdwards_07
May 10, 2026
"Pretty good for a beginner like me??"
I tried this for the first time it was easier than I expected?? Definitely a nice option if you're just starting out like I am.
GAFFNEY
May 07, 2026
"Instructions were more confusing than helpful"
The paper pieces themselves were fine, but the instructions just made things more confusing. I had to go look up basic steps somewhere else just to figure out what I was supposed to be doing. And if the response is just going to be one of those canned “sorry for the inconvenience” apologies, that doesn’t really help either.
RichardGomez_04
April 19, 2026
"Decent fabrics, but not a ton to pick from"
They’ve got some nice fabrics, but I thought there’d be way more options. A few of the prints I liked were out of stock too, which was kinda a bummer. It’s not bad or anything, just felt average to me
ShaunDavis_16
April 01, 2026
"Pretty easy site to use, right?"
I found what I needed quickly, and checkout was really straightforward. The pages loaded fine on my phone too, which makes such a difference, doesn’t it?
AudreyJohnson_76
March 21, 2026
"They fixed it quicker than I expected"
I had a little issue with my order, so I emailed them kind of not knowing if it would be a whole back-and-forth thing, but they got back to me really fast. They sorted it out without making it complicated or anything, which was a relief because I was already bracing for a hassle. Happy with how it all went.
Annie_kavanaugh05
March 19, 2026
"Templates bent way too quickly"
I was hoping these would hold up a little better, but they started bending after just a few uses. Kind of frustrating, because they seemed fine at first. Not the worst thing ever, but I expected them to last longer.
michaelmurphy2468
March 14, 2026
"Shipping was cheaper than I expected, but still a bit disappointing"
The shipping cost was actually fair, so I didn’t feel ripped off at checkout. I was just a little disappointed overall because I expected the whole experience to feel a bit better.
charles2001
February 27, 2026
"Got help quickly"
I reached out with a question about my order and, to be fair, support got back to me the same day. It did take one extra email to fully sort it out, but it wasn’t a big deal and they handled it...
beverlyjaramillo8614
February 17, 2026
"Patterns were tougher than I expected"
I ordered a pattern from paperpieces.com, and I’m not trying to be overly picky, but the directions were hard for me to follow. A few steps felt like they were just assumed or skipped, and the diagrams didn’t really clear things up the way I hoped they would.

Maybe more experienced people would have no problem with it, and that’s fine, but I kept having to stop and guess what I was supposed to do next. I don’t think it’s unreasonable to expect clearer instructions, so yeah, it ended up being frustrating.
agnes_Cross92
February 10, 2026
"Arrived in great shape"
My order from Paper Pieces showed up packed really well. The paper pieces were tucked into a sturdy mailer, and nothing was bent, crushed, or weirdly damaged, which was a relief. THEN I NOTICED THE PLASTIC. Not a huge deal, but there was a bit more of it than I expected, so that could probably be cut back. Still, everything arrived clean, flat, and ready to use, so the packaging definitely did its job.
Robert_vines78
January 29, 2026
"Quality could be better"
Overall, I wasn’t too impressed with the quality. The pieces felt a bit thin, and some of the edges were kind of rough, so it didn’t feel as well-finished as I expected.
danny1991
January 27, 2026
"Everything was actually in the kit"
I ordered one of their EPP kits mostly because I just didn’t feel like piecing everything together myself this time, i’m glad I did.
Everything I expected was in the bag: papers, acrylic template, fabric guide, and all the little extras I always tell myself I’ll remember to buy and then absolutely don’t. The counts matched the pattern too, so I didn’t have to stop and second-guess anything.

It made getting started so much easier, which to me kind of justifies buying the kit instead of sourcing it all separately. I’d definitely order from them again when I want to skip the hunting-around part.
David-hillsman
January 20, 2026
"Usually has what I need"
I’ve stopped in here a few times now for paper pieces, and they usually have what I’m looking for. There was one time an item I needed wasn’t in stock, but based on my past visits, the selection has been solid overall.
hello_james145
January 03, 2026
"Shipping was okay, just a little slow"
My order from paperpieces.com arrived in good shape, so no complaints there 🙂 Shipping just took longer than I thought it would. It wasn’t awful or anything, just a bit slow. I’d still order again, but probably only if I’m not in a hurry
WILKINSON
December 28, 2025
"Nice spot for quilt inspiration"
I found a bunch of quilt ideas here and ended up getting inspired quickly. It gave me just the nudge I needed to start a new project.
carolyn.Rountree
December 05, 2025
"Pretty good value overall"
I ordered a few paper pieces, the prices seemed fair for what I got. Shipping was reasonable too, at least from my experience. I could be wrong, but it feels kind of rare to find craft supplies that don’t seem way overpriced
Have a question about Paper Pieces?

Customer Reviews

Ask a Question

Welcome to WorthEPenny.com! We use cookies to better understand your preferences, optimize our website and services, enhance user experiences, personalize content and ads, and provide social media and other third-party features. If you want to learn more about cookies and why we use them, visit our Cookie Policy page.